Sep 9, 2007

David Copperfield meets David Hume

George Johnson visits the Magic of Consciousness conference in--where else?--Las Vegas.
Sounding more like a professor than a comedian and magician, Teller described how a good conjuror exploits the human compulsion to find patterns, and to impose them when they aren’t really there.

“In real life if you see something done again and again, you study it and you gradually pick up a pattern,” he said as he walked onstage holding a brass bucket in his left hand. “If you do that with a magician, it’s sometimes a big mistake.”

Pulling one coin after another from the air, he dropped them, thunk, thunk, thunk, into the bucket. Just as the audience was beginning to catch on — somehow he was concealing the coins between his fingers — he flashed his empty palm and, thunk, dropped another coin, and then grabbed another from a gentlemen’s white hair. For the climax of the act, Teller deftly removed a spectator’s glasses, tipped them over the bucket and, thunk, thunk, two more coins fell.

As he ran through the trick a second time, annotating each step, we saw how we had been led to mismatch cause and effect, to form one false hypothesis after another. Sometimes the coins were coming from his right hand, and sometimes from his left, hidden beneath the fingers holding the bucket.

He left us with his definition of magic: “The theatrical linking of a cause with an effect that has no basis in physical reality, but that — in our hearts — ought to.”
[via OPP]

Sep 8, 2007

California man walks 150 miles for lurve

He's...

nice place to read a book

My brother links to this photo gallery of gorgeous libraries. Marvels of wood and marble and massive stained glass windows and, of course, books upon books. (I found some of the more ornate entries a bit overwhelming.)

Here's one that will (hopefully) never make the list: Seattle's IKEA Public Library.

Ugly Building to get a facelift?

This is huge. The Ugly Building, long the bane of this blog, isn't going away. It's turning into condos and getting prettier.
The developers plan to convert the vacant Capitol Center office building across from Capitol Lake into eight floors of 36 condos, including a mix of two- and three-bedroom units with 1.75 and two bathrooms in each unit. Pending approval of building permits, remodeling could begin this fall and take a year to complete, said Falkenburg, an Olympia partner with Seattle developer Jim Potter.

The developers have dropped plans to add balconies to the building and have yet to work out details about parking, Falkenburg said.

The development, known as The Views on Fifth Avenue, would include 8,000 square feet of commercial space on the ground floor. The office, built as a bank in the mid-1960s, has been vacant since last year, when the state Department of Corrections moved out for offices in Tumwater.

Falkenburg said the developers have not decided how much the view condos would cost, but one of the development partners this year estimated the range from $600,000 to $1 million. The building offers views of the Capitol Building, Capitol Lake, the Olympic Mountains and Mount Rainier.
And, by consequence, obscures views of the same from many directions.

If it ain't ugly, though, I can probably live with that. Another means of boosting the downtown economy wouldn't be so bad, either. We need a permanent customer pool tax base. (Click to read the nay-saying comments, though. Will residents flock to fill million-dollar condos?)

Update 9/9: stevenl of Olyblog wants to preserve The Ugly Building as-is:
Like the twin WPPSS cooling towers on the Chehalis River Valley near Elma that were never used, this building stands as a monument to our failings, to an era of wrecked expectations, to something I can't quite define at this moment because I'm getting hungry now and want to stop typing. But you know what I mean. Save the Capitol Center Building!

Pac-10 rising

Michigan's upset doesn't look so amazing anymore, as Oregon marched into the Big House and knocked down the reeling Wolverines, 39-7. (Will Lloyd Carr still have a job next week?) UCLA, Cal, and USC are looking good early. ASU's always tough. Add to that a revived Husky squad, and you've got one helluva conference.

Update 9/9: True to form, the Pac-10 went undefeated yesterday.

America's trash....

Is China's second-largest American import. No, we're not talking about Paris Hilton videos:
In an act of macroeconomic karma, materials thrown out by Americans—broken-down auto bodies, old screws and nails, paper—accounted for $6.7 billion in exports to China in 2006, second only to aerospace products. Junkyards may conjure up images of Fred Sanford's ratty collection of castoffs. But these days, scrap dealers are part of a $65 billion industry that employs 50,000 people, who together constitute a significant arc of a virtuous circle. The demand of China's factory bosses for junk—which they recycle to make all the junk Americans buy from China—creates jobs, tamps down the growth of the trade deficit, and might help save the planet.
Daniel Gross hits one of the low points--the rising price of scrap materials encourages theft, especially of easily-obtained metals like copper. Remarkably, though, Gross misses the truly dark side of the trade: e-waste. Not all our trash is being turned into treasure. Not yet, at least.

Huskies to meet Boise State in a classic contest

Boise State charmed the world last year. The Huskies charmed no one. Now both meet in a classic matchup: the hot no-longer-underdogs versus the resurrecting champions of old. What to watch for, saith the Times:
UW coaches say BSU's O-line, which includes All-American candidate left tackle Ryan Clady, could be among the best in the country. UW's front four dominated Syracuse, getting seven sacks and holding the Orange to eight yards rushing, but they will be severely tested today in trying to penetrate the line and get to Broncos running back Ian Johnson, who ran for 1,713 yards last season....

Boise State is much more than gimmick plays, but deception is a major part of its game. Washington coaches say Boise State showed 35 formations on first down in the three games of film they studied from last year and this year.
Saith our neighbor at the Sports Report:
[Bronco QB Taylor] Tharp played well in mop-up duty last year, and played well in the home opener. By all accounts, he wasn’t the most talented of the QBs competing for the starting spot, but was chosen as a senior who will be counted on be steady. Can he rise to the occasion on the road?...

[Husky QB Jake Locker] obviously won’t be able to make it look that easy every week, as a redshirt freshman will stumble at points this year. One has to wonder if this week will be his true baptism against and experienced and well-coached team.
Like Jeff, I'm waffling on this one--so many variables, so many things to like, so many concerns on either side. The Broncos' 0-5 away record against BCS opponents sticks out, but then so does the fact that the Huskies haven't opened 2-0 since 2001.

Broncos 31, Huskies 20. Experience and discipline beats spunk. (That's what happened last night.)

Update: After an exciting first half in which the Huskies jumped out to a 24-10 lead, both teams hunkered down. Locker had bright moments, including a 58-yard TD, but was inconsistent overall. The best TD of the day was a halfback pass by Louis Rankin to Quintin Daniels in the first quarter. Bob Rondeau, Voice of the Huskies, flipped out, shouting that it was "Right out of the Bronco playbook!"

Hampered by turnovers, Boise State couldn't mount a rally, and that was all that was written by her.

Don't bet on sports.

Sep 7, 2007

2007 Spaghetti Bowl photos

Photos of tonight's 31-7 loss to Olympia. Click the title or the timestamp to see all six.


The view from the end zone. Oly warms up in the distance.


At today's pep assembly, we were introduced to a new female Cougar, seen at left. Why do we have a new Cougar? Does anybody know? Isn't one enough?


Capital storms the field in a choking haze.


Our first and only touchdown happened so fast, I barely had time to pull out the camera. There wasn't much to photograph after that.


As the world tilts on its axis, the combined Olympia and Capital bands play "Eye of the Tiger."


That's how the scoreboard would stay.

Cougars fall to Oly, 31-7

The only good thing about a 31-7 game is that the loss stings less than a 21-20 heartbreaker. After the first Capital touchdown in the early minutes, Olympia dominated on both sides of the ball, controlling the pace of the game while making absolutely zero mistakes.

The game looked like it was going to be tight early on. Capital stuffed the Bears' first drive. Oly's defense stood up, forcing a three-and-out and blocking a punt deep in Cougar territory, but Capital held the Bears to a field goal, 7-3.

Two crucial plays shifted the momentum Olympia's way. One was a dropped interception by Riley Wall that could have stopped the Bears' early comeback. The other was a brilliant fake punt call on fourth-and-long close to midfield. The resulting run set up an eventual 24-7 lead, and Capital would never seriously threaten again.

Gotta hand this one to Bill Beattie for perfect play-calling and disciplined execution by a Bears squad that looked hungry to avenge its earlier loss to 2A Tumwater.

So much for my optimism. At least it was non-league.

Added: And it least it was closer than last year.

wearing Andrew's jersey


Blogging neighbor Jeff Nusser wears Seahawk favorite Lofa Tatupu's #51. He asks:
So, what about you? Which jersey do you own? It doesn’t have to be the Seahawks, but you do have to tell us why you picked it.
I don't own a jersey, but tonight at the Spaghetti Bowl, when the upstart Cougs face a humbled Olympia squad, I'll be sporting Andrew Kim's #50.

New coach J.D. Johnson, as a way to heat up our already feverish school spirit, told his players to distribute their practice jerseys to Capital staffmembers. Andrew approached me before school and asked if I'd wear his. I smelled it to make sure it didn't reek of scrimmage, and then draped it over my dress clothes. Had to tuck it in--it came down to my knees.

I wore it all day, and I'll be wearing it this evening when the Cougars take the field. The Olympian calls this one for Oly, but tonight, when the sun sets over Ingersoll and the football gods fly down from Mount Rainier to wreak their havoc, anything is possible.

Capital 28, Olympia 21. Go Cougs!

a wheelchair steered with words

Every time you think of a word, tiny muscle movements in your larynx echo your thought. You "say" the word subvocally, imperceptibly, unconsciously.

Now researchers have developed a wheelchair steered by this natural phenomenon known as subvocalization. For all practical purposes, we now have a simple way to steer things using thoughts.

Below, a video explaining how it works.



The system isn't perfect for severely paralyzed patients who can't move facial muscles, but it's still pretty darn effective.

See also: steering with your tongue.

Sep 6, 2007

Skyward Parent Access: coming to a school near you

A prediction and a question from a little over a year ago:
The Skyward program we use for attendance--or something bigger and/or better--will someday be the place to post grades and comments on student performance, with access for parents, possibly linked to other online programs. The software and hardware are already in place, and the wider culture is ready for it. Are you?
The answer, if you're teaching in the South Sound, had better be yes.
The North Thurston, Rochester, Shelton, Steilacoom Historical, Tenino and Yelm school districts all have the online service available at both the middle and high school levels. The K-8 Griffin School District also has online access to grades for middle school parents.

The Tumwater School District provides online access to high school parents and those with students at Bush Middle School. Tumwater Middle School plans to offer the Internet service by December.

"It's bridging the gap between home and school," Tumwater High Principal Scott Seaman said. "Parents can get immediate feedback."
Here at Capital, we go live sometime this month. I'm already used to the system, but other teachers are a little nervous, and rightly so. Assessment practices vary widely from class to class, simply because of the nature of the content and the assignments offered. Several of my peers are worried that parents will expect "immediate feedback" all the time, when that simply isn't feasible.

Plus, our tech guy is a total noob, and half our computers are down.

Yikes.

gratuitous self-plagiarism--in polyester


Everything old is new again.

Sep 5, 2007

going the distance

Almost a year ago, I wrote:
Talking to a colleague in the history department yesterday, I found out that he's teaching 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th, and 6th periods, which he called "The Marathon." This year my schedule's equally breathless, starting at 1st and running straight through to 5th, with only short breaks and a half hour lunch for respite. I miss that mid-day reflection time, which provided a chance to change tactics if an early lesson bombed.

The trimester is another marathon, but for my first period debate class, it's a marathon sprint, a year's curriculum finished in thirteen weeks.
The situation has changed a little this year. I'm still running the 1st-to-5th marathon, but with an extra added bonus: National Board Certification to fill up my prep period and my remaining free time.

At least we've switched to semesters, which gives five extra weeks for debate. That'll make a huge difference in depth and quality, especially when it comes to Lincoln-Douglas values debate, which requires a crash course in philosophy, ethics, law, and argumentation for baffled novices.

The marathon begins at breakneck speed: I hope to once again learn all my students' names by Friday. Impossible, really, but worth the effort. Seating charts, constant name use, name-based group activities, studying the attendance list, names quizzes. Whatever it takes. I have to know who's waving to me fifty yards down the hall.

After five full years of teaching, I think I've finally reached competence.

Shoreline, Issaquah, Bethel strikes over

Shoreline, Issaquah, and Bethel students are all heading to class, reports today's Seattle Times.
Elizabeth Beck, co-president of Shoreline Education Association, which represents the district's teachers, said the teacher's union approved the contract with a 79 percent majority....

Issaquah students will go to school as scheduled today after members of the Issaquah Education Association voted 508-11 to approve the contract....

And Bethel teachers, who have been striking since Aug. 30, when school was supposed to have started, will return to their classrooms Wednesday after approving a new contract Tuesday night. Members of the Bethel Education Association voted 84 percent in favor of the new two-year contract.
I said I was 90% sure that Bethel's strike was done. I'm sure the reader will pardon the excess 6% confidence.

Now--back to school.

Sep 4, 2007

no brain is an island

Stuart Derbyshire, reviewing Chris Frith's Making up the Mind: How the Brain Creates our Mental World, wants to rescue free will from neuroscience. He focuses on schizophrenia because of its challenge to stable conceptions of the self, and because of its mysterious etiology and causality.

In doing so, however, Derbyshire makes two minor but bothersome errors. First, he ignores the vast number of pathologies where causality is better understood. Second, following Frith, he ignores the vast body of recent neuroscientific research on schizophrenia. Considering the plight of schizophrenic patients, Derbyshire quotes Frith, who writes,
‘There are no objective physical signs of schizophrenia. The diagnosis is based on what the patient tells the doctor. Patients say that they hear voices when no one is there (false perceptions – hallucinations). Patients describe how they are persecuted by their colleagues at work when there is no evidence that this is the case (false beliefs – delusions). Patients with hallucinations and delusions are sometimes described as being out of touch with reality. But it is the mental world, rather than the physical world, that they have lost touch with.’
Their fragmented consciousness is hidden from immediate view, but that doesn't make it impervious to objective measurement.

Schizophrenia, according to recent research, is associated with reduced cerebral laterality, reduced amygdala volume, frontal-subcortical circuit dysfunction, gray matter excesses in the caudate nucleus--the list goes on and on. Some of these differences might even be heritable.

In summary:
Until recently, the dominant view was that schizophrenia patients have limited, if any, neuropsychological impairments, and those that are observed are only secondary to the florid symptoms of the disorder. This view has dramatically changed.
Errors aside, what about Derbyshire's broader point, the underappreciated role of the will? Current neurosciencelooks for cause and effect in patterns of brain activity. This, according to Derbyshire, takes too narrow a view.
Frith’s dual contentions that reality is illusory and free will is just a manufactured state of mind are both far too strong. Our limited direct access to the world ‘as it truly is’ is certainly a real problem. It is a problem because the world does not divide itself into fact-sized chunks that can be consumed by our senses. Whether a forest is perceived as a unit or an aggregation of many trees is arbitrary, just as it is arbitrary whether we observe leaves as independent or continuous with twigs and whether the twigs are independent or continuous and so on ad infinitum. Nature does not inherently divide itself into salient pieces, and what is salient or important is only revealed in the relationships within nature....

[I]t is only through our relationship with the world that we can come to divide the world and begin to describe it. The facts that we can lay claim to about the world are arbitrary in so far as they are selected from an almost infinite number of potential facts, but we can, nevertheless, have great confidence that the facts we are gathering are real. We can have this confidence because our actions based upon those facts generally lead to expected outcomes – trains move forward through space, telephones transmit recognisable voice signals, medical intervention saves lives, and so on. These happy outcomes indicate that our division of the world is grounded in reality and that although our facts are arbitrarily selected we are not making them up as we go along.

In short, Frith misses, or understates, the role of inquiry in constructing a real representation of the world. Inquiry brings human beings into an understanding of the world that continues to more closely approximate the way the world truly is. The constraints that our brain places upon inquiry do not dictate reality but rather allow us the freedom to interrogate reality....

The fundamental mistake that Frith makes – and this is a common error – is to believe that agency or free will are products only of the human brain. The brain is necessary but it is not sufficient, and chasing agency into the brain will only yield disappointment or, in this case, a sense that agency is illusory. If agency is not merely a product of ordinary brains, then it follows that abnormal brains might not be the whole or only answer when there are psychiatric problems and delusions of agency such as in schizophrenia.
Derbyshire hints at, but never fleshes out, the processes involved in "inquiry." For this, we have to turn to other writings, for example, an attempt to answer the politically charged question, "Can fetuses feel pain?"
[C]onscious function can only emerge if the proper psychological content and environment has been provided. Before infants can think about objects or events, or experience sensations and emotion, the contents of thought must have an independent existence in their mind. This is something that is achieved through continued brain development in conjunction with discoveries made in action and in patterns of mutual adjustment and interactions with a caregiver. The development of representational memory, which allows infants to respond and to learn from stored information rather than respond to material directly available, may be considered a building block of conscious development. Representational memory begins to emerge as the frontal cortex develops between two and four months of age, supported by developments in the hippocampus that facilitate the formation, storage, and retrieval of memories. From this point tagging in memory is possible, or labelling as "something," all the objects, emotions, and sensations that appear or are felt. When a primary caregiver points to a spot on the body and asks "does that hurt?" he or she is providing content and enabling an internal discrimination and with it experience. This type of interaction provides content and symbols that allow infants to locate and anchor emotions and sensations. It is in this way that infants can arrive at a particular state of being within their own mind. Although pain experience is individual, it is created by a process that extends beyond the individual.
I sense an affinity between Derbyshire's position and what Russian developmental psychologist described as cultural mediation. We form and re-form the experiences of those around us, shaping and re-shaping the brain--ours and others'. In grand metaphysical style, you might say that every "I" is a "we."

shameless self-plagiarism

Oh, Curtis. What have ye wrought?

photos of Harbor Days

Saturday night we kids took the folks out to dinner at the Water Street in downtown Olympia. Afterward, we headed over to the pier to gawk at the classic boats. The photos below were taken by my wife and me, using Mom and Dad's camera. Seven in all; click the title if you see only 3.








defining down the divine

Joe Carter, after Roy Clouser, makes an assertion that not only falls flat, but in doing so, makes a pedestal for a lovely pun. Just wait.

Carter, probably responding to the blogosphere buzz over John Allen Paulos' article on religiously-informed mathematics, writes,
A belief is a religious belief, says Clouser, provided that (1) It is a belief in something(s) or other as divine, or (2) It is a belief concerning how humans come to stand in relation to the divine. The divine, according to Clouser, is whatever is "just there." He contends that self-existence is the defining characteristic of divinity, so that the control of theories by a belief about what is self-existent is the same as control by a divinity belief and thus amounts to religious control of all theories.

Whether we refer to it as being self-existent, uncaused, radically independent, etc., it is the point beyond which nothing else can be reduced. Unless we posit an infinite regress of dependent existences, we must ultimately arrive at an entity that fits the criteria for the divine.

Different traditions, religions, and belief systems may disagree about what or who has divine status, or whether such an ontological concept should be considered a "religious belief." But what they all agree upon is that something has such a status. A theist, for instance, will say that the divine is God while a materialist will claim that matter is what fills the category of divine. Therefore, if we examine our concepts in enough detail, we discover that at a deeper level we're not agreeing on what the object is that we're talking about. Our explanations and theories about things will vary depending on what is presupposed as the ultimate explainer. And the ultimate explainer can only be the reality that has divine status.
I find it fascinating that Clouser and Carter don't see the slick rhetorical move in the definition. If the "divine" is defined into "what is 'just there,'" why use such a loaded word? The answer: it's just a more sophisticated way to say, "Atheism (or naturalism) is a religion." And, as others have famously pointed out, not-stamp-collecting is a hobby.

If Clouser were intellectually honest* I wish he'd use a more neutral term: Being, perhaps, or The Ground. I'd prefer the latter. Naturalists may love the universe, but they don't worship The Ground she walks on.

Don't say you weren't warned.



*See comments below.

Sep 3, 2007

Bethel strike over?

It could be history a mere six days after beginning, KOMO reports:
Striking teachers and the Bethel School District reached a tentative contract agreement Monday that could end a short strike. Union officials say teachers could be in their classrooms as soon as Wednesday.

Bethel Education Association President Tom Cruver did not release any details of the settlement, which came after 25 hours of weekend negotiations, but he called it fair.

"It would be fair to say that both sides worked to find a middle ground," he said.

Teachers will vote Tuesday evening. If they ratify the contract, school will resume on Wednesday, Cruver said.
Based on Cruver's words, I'd wager with about 90% confidence that the teachers will ratify the contract.

Across Puget Sound, the Shoreline EA, meanwhile, moves closer to picketing.